In this issue of PNAS, Wei and colleagues demonstrate that
the Nuclear factor erythroid 2-related factor 2 (Nrf2), a
well-known cell-intrinsic cytoprotective factor and critical
regulator of the anti-oxidant response plays an important
function in reparative angiogenesis by suppressing the
antiangiogenic effects of Semaphorin 6A (Sema6A), a
membrane-associated guidance molecule expressed by
neurons during retinal ischemia (1).
Ischemic vasoproliferative retinopathies such as diabetic
retinopathy, retinal vein occlusion and retinopathy of
prematurity are considered some of the main causes of
visual impairment and blindness in adults and children
respectively. These ocular diseases are characterized
by a retinal microvascular degeneration followed by an
abnormal intravitreal neovascularization. One of the major
concerns about ischemic retinopathies is to understand the
mechanism by which retinal revascularization proceeds
aberrantly towards the vitreous instead of within the inner
limiting membrane. Recently, it has been hypothesized
that some forms of repulsive factors interfered with normal
revascularization of the vaso-obliterated regions of the
retina, and as a result led to misguidance of vessels towards
the vitreous (2,3). However, none of these repulsive factors
was associated before to key regulatory molecules such as
Nrf2 that has the potential to reprogram ischemic tissue
toward a neurovascular repair response.
Oxidative stress is considered a significant trigger of
the tissue damage in ischemic retinopathies (4). Nrf2 is
an important suppressor of the oxidative damage in the
tissues and therefore it has become a key player in the
protection against retinal diseases. It has been reported
that the absence of functional Nrf2 in the retina reduces
the ability to respond to oxidative stress and accelerate
degenerative changes in a model of ischemic retinopathy (5).
In a previous study, Wei et al. proposed that the Nrf2
activation during developmental angiogenesis in the
retina has a proangiogenic effect (6). However, its role in
ischemic vasoproliferative retinopathies remained poorly
understood. Herein, by using the mouse model of oxygeninduced
retinopathy (OIR), a well characterized model that
mimics the two phases that occur in ischemic retinopathies
in humans, Wei and colleagues showed that Nrf2 can
regulate revascularization of the neuroretina after ischemia
by coordinating neuronal and endothelial elements. To
demonstrate the reparative angiogenic mechanism of
Nrf2 in OIR, Wei and colleagues focus their attention
particularly in the site of vaso-obliteration and reparative
angiogenesis in OIR. The authors found a major expression
and nuclear localization of Nrf2 (activation) in retinal
ganglion cells located in the avascular retina associated to
the reparative angiogenesis. Conversely, genetic ablation
of Nrf2 dramatically impeded vascular regeneration and
increased pathological neovascularization in the retinas
of animals subjected to OIR. Importantly, the absence of
Nrf2 was accompanied by an increased expression of the
antiangiogenic/repulsive factor Sema6A in the ganglion cell
neurons from ischemic inner retina in OIR mice. These
results, along with other studies (2,3) further support the
evidences that neuron repulsive cues increase in the ischemic
retina of OIR animals inhibits vascular regeneration and/or
promotes pathological neovascularization. Distinctively, in
this study no appreciable changes on other repulsive cues
were detected suggesting that the suppression of vascular
regrowth in the absence of Nrf2 is speciff cally attributed to the neuronal repulsive factor Sema6A, which has also been
shown to exert antiangiogenic activity in other models (7,8),
but never proven to be regulated by Nrf2. The regulation
of Sema6A by Nrf2 in hypoxic stress-injured neurons was
HIF-1α-dependent, which is not surprising, since HIF-1
is part of the primary cellular response to hypoxia and can
activate a range of genes involved in several cellular process.
Impaired ischemic neurovascular remodeling by
expressing neuronal guidance cues, such as Sema3A,
Sema3E and Sema6A, uncovers an important mechanism
that involves the semaphorins in the inhibition of the
reparative angiogenesis into the hypoxic/ischemic zone in
vasoproliferative retinopathies. Interestingly, and in contrast
to other secreted semaphorins, Sema6A has been shown to
be a membrane-associated guidance molecule that suggests
its vasorepulsive effect by direct contact between endothelial
cells and retinal ganglion cells.
To emphasize the hypothesis that Sema6A mediates
the suppression of revascularization in the retina in vivo,
the investigators tested the effects of extracellular Sema6A
on endothelial cell motility. They found that Sema6A
induced cellular contraction, inhibited cell migration and
decreased tube formation on endothelial cell cultures in a
dose-dependent fashion. Importantly, Sema6A suppresses
migration via activation of Notch signaling, a well
characterized mechanism implicated in the regulation of
angiogenesis.
Given the antiangiogenic and vasorepulsive properties
of Sema6A, it was logic for the authors to propose that
local inhibition of Sema6A would limit the invasion of the
pathologic new vessels toward the vitreous. This hypothesis
was confirmed when the intravitreal administration of
lentivirus containing small hairpin RNA (shRNA) targeting
Sema6A significantly reduced avascular area and inhibited
pathologic preretinal neovascularization in the absence or
presence of Nrf2 in animals subjected to the OIR model.
This result raises the possibility of Sema6A inhibition as a
therapy for pathologic retinal neovascularization. Also given
the important role of Nrf2 in the reparative angiogenesis
during OIR, the authors suggest that pharmacological
enhancement of Nrf2 could be a novel therapeutic strategy
for this condition. To prove this, Wei and collaborators
performed intravitreal injections of synthetic triterpenoids,
which are potent inducers of Nrf2, and as they expected,
an increase in vascular regeneration as well as a suppression
of preretinal neovascularization it was detected in OIR
animals. These findings strongly suggested Nrf2 as a
therapeutic target in diseases related to ischemia-induced
angiogenesis in the retina and the central nervous system.
The study by Wei and colleagues represents a significant
contribution to the mechanisms implicated in development
of ischemic retinopathies. This elegant study highlights
the critical role played by neurons and endothelial cells in
governing vascular repair. The mechanism provided by the
investigators addresses a framework for understanding how
the presence of vasorepulsive factors in the avascular and
severely hypoxic retina form a chemical barrier preventing
vascular ingrowth into the ischemic zone. This study also
provides a novel link between Nrf2 and Sema6A. The
observation that Nrf2 can regulate local Sema6A expression
serves as a guide for future studies regarding the possible
role of Nrf2 in modulating other semaphorins or factors
implicated in diff erent pathologic conditions such as stroke
or cancer. The fact that Nrf2 and Sema6A participate as
regulators of the neuroretinal response to ischemia suggests
a therapeutic strategy directed at shifting the neuroretina
toward a repair response, specifically by promoting
revascularization.This might involve enhancing Nrf2
activation to influence the overall neurovascular response,
or suppressing Sema6A and its critical antiangiogenic
effect. Finally, the work by Wei et al., provides a
valuable conceptual framework with fruitful avenues for
future investigations and a blueprint to understand the
pathogenesis of other ischemic disorders.