Purpose: Strabismus is associated with a higher prevalence of idiopathic thoracic scoliosis (ITS) in children. This study aims to investigate whether superior oblique palsy (SOP) poses a higher risk for developing ITS among children and adolescents.
Methods: A cross-sectional study. The study group comprised 347 consecutive candidates for SOP surgery aged 4 to 18 years; Patients within the same age range with ocular trauma were enrolled as the control group. Preoperative chest plain radiographs were used to measure the Cobb angle. Demographic information and clinical data, including diopter, best corrected visual acuity, deviation degree, and binocular function, were analyzed.
Results: A significantly higher prevalence of ITS was found in study group compared with control group (12.68% vs 4.18%,p< 0.001) . Additionally, the mean Cobb angle was lagrger in SOP group than that in control group (5.02°±3.87° vs 3.84°±3.09°, p < 0.001). Males in SOP group showed a higher prevalence of ITS (12.9% vs 2.87%, p = 0.007), but there was no significant difference in females between two groups (12.3% vs 7.69%, p = 0.295). Good near stereopsis acuity was significantly associated with high prevalence of thoracic scoliosis (p<0.001). Multivariate logistic regression analysis revealed that a large distant magnitude of deviation (>20PD) and near stereoacuity were significantly associated with ITS.
Conclusions: Patients with SOP have a significantly higher risk of developing idiopathic thoracic scoliosis, especially those with good near stereoscopic and large distant magnitude of deviation.
The mean Cobb angle was significantly larger in the SOP group (5.02, 95%CI 4.61 to 5.43 degree) compared to the control group (3.84, 95%CI 3.48 to 4.20); P <0.001), Furthermore, there were gender-specific The prevalence of ITS in males with SOP was significantly higher than that in the control group (12.9% vs. 2.87%; P = 0.007), whereas no significant difference was found between the two groups in females (12.3% vs 7.69%; P = 0.30. Table 1). Among the 44 patients with ITS in the SOP group, 43 revealed curvatures greater than or equal to 10° but less than 20°. Only one patient exhibited a curvature exceeding 20°. Of these, 28 (63.6%) were located on the right, and 16 (36.4%) were on the left (Figure 1B). There was also no significant correlation between the direction of the ITS and the paralytic eye (χ 2 = 0.04; P = 0.84). ITS was distributed in the proximal thoracic (PT) in 10 patients (22.73%), the main thoracic (MT) region in 25 patients (56.82%), and the thoracolumbar (TL) region in 9 patients (20.45%) (Figure 1C). In the control group, 12 patients were found to have scoliosis of less than 20°, with a mean curvature of the scoliosis was 13.93 ± 2.60°. Of these, 10 (83.3%) were bent to the right and 2 (16.7%) to the left (Figure 1B). Scoliosis was distributed in the main thoracic spine in 10 patients (83.3%) and thoracolumbar spine in 2 (16.7%) (Figure 1C).
Characteristics
|
Groups |
P value |
|
SOP |
Ocular trauma |
||
Number of patients |
347 |
287 |
|
Age (years)a |
6.93 ± 3.16 |
7.23 ± 3.06 |
0.219 |
Gender (ratio) Male Female |
130/347 (37.46%) 217/347 (52.54%) |
209/287 (72.82%) 78/287 (27.18%) |
<0.001 |
Mean Cobb anglea |
5.02° ± 3.87° |
3.84° ± 3.09° |
<0.001 |
Prevalence of ITS Male Female Overall |
28/217(12.90%) 16/130(12.30%) 44/347(12.68%) |
6/209(2.87%) 6/78(7.69%) 12/287(4.18%) |
0.007 0.295 P< 0.001 |
Clinical features |
Children, No. |
P value |
|
With ITS (n=44) |
Without ITS (n=303) |
||
Sex Male Femal assessed age (year) |
28(63.6%) 16(36.4%) |
189(62.4%) 114(37.6%) |
1.00 |
<12 |
37 (84.1%) |
282 (93.1%) |
|
≥12 Onset time (year) ≤1 >1 Duration (year) ≤5 >5 Amblyopia yes no Anisometropia yes no Near magnitude of deviation, PD ≤20 >20 |
7 (15.9%)
20 (45.5%) 24 (54.5%)
30 (68.2%) 14 (31.8%)
5 (11.4%) 39 (88.6%)
2 (4.5%) 42 (95.5%)
36 (81.8%) 8 (18.2%) |
21 (6.9%)
160 (52.8%) 143 (47.2%)
215 (71.0%) 88 (29.0%)
17 (77.3%) 286 (94.4%)
17 (5.6%) 281 (94.4%)
250 (82.5%) 53 (17.5%) |
0.067
0.42
0.725
0.176
1.00
1.00 |
Distant magnitude of deviation, PD |
|
|
|
≤20 |
30 (68.2%) |
244 (80.5%) |
|
>20 |
14 (31.8%) |
59 (19.5%) |
0.074 |
Near stereoacuity (acs) |
|
|
|
≤400 |
27 (61.4%) |
37 (12.2%) |
|
Nil |
17 (38.6%) |
266 (87.8%) |
<0.001 |
Distant stereoacuity |
|
|
|
≤400 |
2 (4.5%) |
9 (3.0%) |
|
Nil |
42 (95.5%) |
294 (97.0%) |
0.637 |
Torsion degree |
20.59±15.17) |
19.60±11.07 |
0.678 |
Abnormal head position |
|
|
|
yes |
34 (77.3%) |
258 (85.1%) |
|
no |
10 (22.7%) |
45 (14.9%) |
0.188 |
(A). It was significantly higher in the SOP group (12.68%) than in the trauma group (4.18%) (χ 2=14.09, p < 0.001). Most direction of ITS distributed in the right (63.6%, 28/44 and 83.3%, 10/12) and a small amount distributed in the left (36.4%, 16/44 and 16.7%, 2/12) (B). The two groups’ patients mainly distributed in main thoracic (T6–T10, MT) (56.82%, 25/44; 83.3%, 10/12) (C). Position of Cobb angle was divided into four sections as follows: proximal thoracic (T2–T5, PT), main thoracic (T6–T10, MT), thoracolumbar (T11–T12, TL) and lumbar (L1–L5, L).
In the SOP group, the prevalence of ITS was three times higher than that in the control group. The prevalence of ITS was associated with the magnitude of distant deviation and near stereo function; specifically, a higher likelihood of ITS was observed in SOP patients with good near stereo acuity. The incidence of ITS was not correlated with the age of onset, disease duration, amblyopia, anisometropia, near-vertical deviation, distance stereoacuity, AHP, or fundus torsion.
Year |
Region |
Study population |
Number of IS patients |
Age (years) |
Prevalence (%) |
Screening methods |
|
Zou Y et al. |
2022 |
Zhejiang, Hangzhou |
45547 |
1766 |
6-17 |
3.87% |
Adam’s forward bending test |
Hu M et al. |
2022 |
Shanghai |
10731 |
213 |
11-16 |
1.98% |
Adam’s forward bending test |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Scoliometer measurements Whole-spine X-ray examination |
Zheng et al. |
2016 |
Wuxi, Jiangsu |
11024 |
282 |
6-13 |
2.56% |
Adam’s forward bending test |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Scoliometer measurements Whole-spine X-ray examination |
Fan H et al. |
2016 |
Guangdong |
99695 |
5125 |
10-19 |
5.14% |
Adam’s forward bending test |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Scoliometer measurements Whole-spine X-ray examination |
Huang N et al. |
2011 |
Guangzhou, Guangdong |
30142 |
211 |
7-20 |
0.70% |
Adam’s forward bending test Whole-spine X-ray examination |
Lee JY et al. |
2014 |
Korean |
37856 |
71 |
11 |
0.19% |
Moiré topography Whole-spine X-ray examination |
Suh S et al. |
2011 |
Korean |
1134890 |
37339 |
10-14 |
3.26% |
Adam’s forward bending test |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Scoliometer measurements Whole-spine X-ray examination |
Ueno M et al. |
2011 |
Tokyo |
255875 |
2225 |
11-14 |
0.87% |
Moiré topography Whole-spine X-ray examination |
We observed a higher incidence of ITS in subjects exhibiting near-stereoscopic functioning compared to those without. Impaired posture control has been implicated as the primary factor contributing to the onset and progression of scoliosis in individuals with strabismus, due to abnormal binocular vision and musculoskeletal deformities[22, 23]. Postural control is a complex multisensory function that requires the collaboration of visual, proprioceptive, vestibular, and somatosensory functions. Children and adolescents predomiantly rely on their visual perception to maintain postural control[24]. Evidence suggests that individuals with binocular vision exhibit superior posture control compared to those relying on monocular viewing[25, 26]. Children with strabismus had near-stereoscopic functioning may better maintain stable postural control, inadvertently prolonging abnormal posture, which can lead to the development of ITS as they age. Furthermore, patients with SOP need AHP to maintain their binocular function, resulting in secondary facial and sternocleidomastoid muscle asymmetry. This asymmetry can lead to an imbalance of the back muscles, subsequently altering the thoracic spine position and ultimately causing scoliosis. No significant difference in ITS prevalence was observed between patients with and without AHP in our study. However, the retrospective nature of our study may have the limited the detail and accuracy of AHO records. Future studies will utilize more comprehensive and accurate AHP data to assess postural control and the incidence of ITS in patients with strabismus.
Our data also indicate the possibility of residual AHP after strabismus surgery in children with strabismus should be considered preoperatively. A previous study reported a 68% success rate in eliminating significant abnormal head posture with strabismus surgery in children with SOP, while about 32% of children continued to exhibit noticeable AHP despite successful strabismus correction. Older age at surgery and tight sternocleidomastoid muscle were identified as factors associated with the residual AHP[27]. Our study supports the notion that a higher incidence of ITS is present in children with SOP, especially in older patients. Those with evident ITS have a high likelihood of retaining some degree of abnormal posture, including abnormal head posture, even after successful strabismus surgery.
The current study has several limitations. Firstly, we only analyzed only patients with strabismus who underwent surgical treatment, excluding those treated with prism. Patients treated with prism may have experienced smaller deviations and shorter AHP durations of AHP due to earlier treatment. Secondly, as a retrospective study, our ability to assess whether scoliosis in strabismus can gradually improve with the correction of deviation is limited. We did not symmetrical and functional analysis of the back muscles in scoliosis patients, nor did we perform a detailed evaluation of AHP due to the study’s the retrospective design. Therefore, a prospective clinical study is necessary to obtain solid regarding the evidence of idiopathic scoliosis and the risk factors associated with SOP patients. Previous studies have shown a significantly higher prevalence of ITS in girls compared to boys[16,19]; however, achieving gender matching is challenging due to the nature of eye injuries.
Patients with SOP exhibit a significantly higher risk of developing idiopathic thoracic scoliosis, particularly those with near stereoacuity and a large magnitude of distant deviation. Early intervention is likely to decrease the incidence and progression of ITS. Nveertheless, the role of AHP in the onset and progression of ITS still warrants a prospective study.
None
None
(I)Conception and design: Xinping Yu, Shihuai Nie
(II) Administrative support: Xinping Yu, Shihuai Nie
(III) Provision of study materials or patients: Xinping Yu, Shihuai Nie
(IV) Collection and assembly of data: Yongguang Yuan, Ming Zhou
(V) Data analysis and interpretation: Yongguang Yuan, Ming Zhou
(VI) Manuscript writing: Yongguang Yuan, Xinping Yu
(VII) Final approval of manuscript: All authors
This work is supported grants from the National Natural Science Foundation of China grant NSFC (82070995).
None of the authors has any conflicts of interest to disclose.All authors have declared in the completed the ICMJE uniform disclosure form.
None
This study involves human participants and ethical approval (2023KYPJ271) was obtained from the Institutional Review Board of Zhongshan Ophthalmic Center, Sun Yat-sen University. Informed written consent was obtained from guardians of all included participants, as they were all children under the age of 18..
None
This is an Open Access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons AttributionNonCommercial-NoDerivs 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0), which permits the non-commercial replication and distribution of the article with the strict proviso that no changes or edits are made and the original work is properly cited (including links to both the formal publication through the relevant DOI and the license).