经验交流

内地与香港眼科住院医师规范化培训体系的比较

Comparison of resident ophthalmologists’ training mode between mainland and Hong Kong

:137-144
 
培养合格的眼科医师对于防盲治盲工作、为人民提供优质眼健康服务是十分重要的,不同地区的住院医师规范化培训各有特点。文章从各个方面比较了内地与香港眼科住院医师规范化培训体系的异同,包括培训对象、培训师资、轮转阶段和要求、考核机制。香港的培训体系时间为6年,大致上相当于住院医师规范化培训和专科医师规范化培训结合在一起。通过比较两者的差异,有助于我们结合自己的实际情况,改进内地的眼科学住院医师教育培养体系,也为下一步开展眼科专科医师规范化培训提供参考。
The training of qualified ophthalmologists holds paramount significance in preventing blindness, treating eye diseases, and delivering optimal eye health services to the people. Given the unique nature of standardized residency training across geographical regions, this study delves into the comparative analysis of ophthalmology residency standardized training systems in the Mainland and Hong Kong. Specifically, we examine the the similarities and disparities in multiple facets, encompassing trainees' profiles, faculty expertise, rotation phases and prerequisites, as well as assessment methodologies. Notably, the training system in Hong Kong has a duration of 6 years, approximating the combined length of standardized residency training and standardized specialist training. By comparing the differences, we aim to facilitate the refinement of ophthalmology residency education and training in Mainland China, tailored to our specific context, while also serving as a reference for advancing standardized ophthalmology specialist training initiatives.
教学专栏

眼科住院医师规范化培训前医师职业认同感调查

A survey on professional identity of ophthalmology residents before standardized resident training

:394-401
 

目的:了解目前眼科住院医师规范化培训前职业认同感现状,并探讨相关影响因素。方法:于2024年7—8月,通过问卷调查法调查64名临床医学眼科住培医师,了解其住院医师规范化培训前的职业认同感现状和影响因素,同时探讨规范化培训对于其职业认同感的影响及作用,通过描述性分析、t检验、单因素方差分析、Pearson相关性分析、多元线性回归分析等方法对相关数据进行分析。结果:规范化培训前,职业认同感评分、职业认知、职业情感、职业承诺、职业行为、职业期望、职业价值观等评分分别为(143.16±12.25)(3.60 ± 0.94)(3.98 ± 0.71)(3.61 ± 1.01)(3.89 ± 0.653.84 ± 0.78)(3.71 ± 0.86)分。规范化培训后,眼科住培医师职业期望评分略有降低,与规范化培训前比较差异有统计学意义 (均P  < 0.01), 其他职业认同度部分条目评分在规范化培训前后比较差异无统计学意义(均P > 0.05)。女生对于眼科医学的职业情感(P = 0.01)及职业价值观高于男生(P = 0.03)。本科时担任学生干部的眼科住培医师职业情感高于非学生干部的学生(P < 0.01)。第一选择为眼科的眼科住培医师的医学职业期望(P  < 0.01)和职业价值观更高((P = 0.02)。而学历、临床医学志愿选择与职业认同感差异均统计学意义(均P > 0.05)。此外,规范化培训一定程度增强了眼科住培医师的显微操作能力和职业信心。结论:住院医师规范化培训前眼科住培医师的职业认同感较高,但仍有待进一步提高。眼科住培医师的职业认同感与职业看法、培训内容、教学资源等因素密切相关。

Objective: To investigate the current status of professional identity among ophthalmology residents before standardized resident training and to explore the influencing factors. Methods: A survey was conducted from July to August 2024 involving 64 clinical ophthalmology residents. The survey assessed their professional identity before standardized resident training and examined the impact and role of pre-residency training on their professional identity. Descriptive analysis, t-tests, univariate analysis, Pearson correlation analysis, and multiple linear regression were used to analyze the data. Results: Before pre-residency training, the scores for overall professional identity, professional cognition, professional emotion, professional commitment, professional behavior, professional expectations, and professional values were (143.16 ± 12.25), (3.60 ± 0.94), (3.98 ± 0.71), (3.61 ± 1.01), (3.89 ± 0.65), (3.84 ± 0.78), and (3.71 ± 0.86), respectively. However, after pre-residency training, the score for professional expectations among ophthalmology residents decreased slightly (P < 0.01), while no significant statistical differences were observed in other items related to professional identity (all P > 0.05). Female residents had higher scores in professional emotion (P = 0.01) and professional values (P = 0.03) than male residents. Ophthalmology residents who had served as student leaders during undergraduate studies had higher scores in professional emotion (P < 0.01). Residents who chose ophthalmology as their first preference had higher scores in professional expectations (P  < 0.01) and professional values (P = 0.02). However, no significant differences were found among educational levels, clinical medicine preferencesand professional identity. In addition, pre-residency training enhanced the residents micro-surgical skills and professional confidence. Conclusions: The professional identity of clinical ophthalmology medical students before standardized resident training is relatively high but still needs improvement. Professional identity is closely related to factors such as professional views, training content, and teaching resources.

论著

并轨住院医师规范化培训的眼科专业学位硕士研究生科研能力现状与思考

Current situation and thinking of scientific researchability for postgraduates with professional degree inophthalmology under the mode of mergingresidency training

:468-476
 
 目的:了解医学专业学位硕士(专硕)研究生培养并轨住院医师规范化培训制度下的眼科专硕科研能 力现状,并提出提升科研能力的对策。方法:对哈尔滨医科大学三所附属医院眼科学76名不同年级 专硕研究生的科研能力现状、阻碍科研学习的因素、科研训练意愿等进行问卷调查。结果:在目前 的培养模式下,专硕科研和临床知识基础相对薄弱及临床学习任务繁重是科研学习的主要障碍。 结论:提出教学基地可以因需施教、提供多模式科研训练;强化临床诊疗培训为科研思维培养助 力;导师可以结合新时代发展背景优化科研选题策略、拓宽学生科研视野等措施。
Objective: To understand the current situation of scientific research ability of postgraduates with professional degrees in ophthalmology and put forward improvement measures. Methods: A questionnaire survey was conducted on the current situation of scientific research ability, scientific research obstacles and scientific research training willingness, 76 postgraduate students of different grades majoring in ophthalmology of three affiliated hospitals of Harbin Medical University were involved. Results: Under the merging residency training system, the foundation of scientific research and clinical knowledge of postgraduates is relatively weak, and the heavy clinical learning task were the main obstacles to scientific research of postgraduates. Conclusion: It is proposed that the teaching bases could provide multi-mode scientific research training to cater to students' individual needs. Not only clinical diagnosis and treatment training could be strengthened to cultivate students’ scientific research thinking, but scientific research topic selection strategy could be optimized by to meet the demand for development of times and broaden students’ scientific research vision.
教学专栏

眼科住院医师规范化培训中人文素养培育的实践与探索

Practice and exploration of cultivating humanistic qualities in standardized training of ophthalmology residents

:402-407
 
在眼科住院医师规范化培训中,医学人文素质的培养对医患沟通能力与职业素养的塑造具有重要价值。医学人文不仅关乎医生的执业能力,更直接影响医疗服务的质量与患者满意度。文章分析了当前眼科住培医师人文素养教育现状及其重要性。在此基础上,提出了培养住培医师的人文素质的方法和途径:1)通过入培前的人文素养专题培训,强化住培医师的医患沟通意识,使其在进入临床实践前就树立正确的人文理念;2)借助医院服务中心的实践活动,让住培医师亲身参与患者服务,从而培养他们的同理心,更好地理解患者的需求与感受;3)开展医学人文读书活动,引导住培医师阅读经典人文著作,深化他们的人文情怀,提升职业素养;4)组织科室人文析议会,针对临床实践中常见的伦理困境进行研讨,帮助住培医师学会在复杂情境中做出合理决策;5)实施思政与医学人文融合的实践,拓展住培医师的人文视野,使其在专业技能提升的同时,不忘人文初心。该文旨在为眼科住培医师的人文素质培养提供理论支持和实践指导。通过这些方法的实施,期望培养出更多具备高人文素养的眼科医疗专业人才。
Strengthening medical humanities education is of vital significance in the standardized training of ophthalmology residents, as it contributes to enhancing their doctor-patient communication skills and professional ethics. This paper examines the current situation and significance of humanities education for ophthalmology residents. On this basis, the paper suggests five concrete methods and approaches for fostering residents' humanistic qualities, such as: (1) strengthening doctor-patient communication awareness through pre-training humanities courses to establish a proper humanistic mindset before clinical practice; (2) developing empathy by participating in hospital service center activities through hands-on patient service experiences; (3) deepening humanistic sentiment and enhancing professional ethics through medical humanities reading activities featuring classical works; (4) discussing clinical ethical dilemmas via departmental humanities analysis meetings to help residents develop decision-making skills in complex scenarios; (5) expanding humanistic horizons through the integration of ideological and political education with medical humanities practice, ensuring professional skill development aligns with humanistic principles. This paper aims to offer theoretical support and practical guidance for the humanities education of ophthalmology residents, with the objective of cultivating more ophthalmology professionals with both clinical excellence and high humanistic caliber.
论著

督导式教学门诊在眼科住院医师规范化培训中的实践

Application of supervised teaching clinic in standardized training of ophthalmology residents

:477-481
 
目的:探讨督导式教学门诊在眼科住院医师规范化培训中的具体实践和教学效果。方法:通过合理排班、限制号源等措施设立每周固定的督导式教学门诊时间,安排老师和学员出诊;在教学门诊开展4个月后,通过问卷调查和临床技能考核的形式采集反馈意见并评估教学效果。 结果:共有16名老师和8名学员参加了督导式教学门诊,调查问卷结果显示100%的带教老师和学员认可该教学模式,参加过教学门诊的学员临床技能考核得分显著高于对照组(t =3.631, P<0.05)。结论:督导式教学门诊应用于眼科住院医师规范化培训具有实际可行性,并可以提高学员的临床技能水平。
Objective: To explore the application and effects of supervised teaching clinic in standardized training of ophthalmology residents. Methods: A weekly supervised teaching clinic was set through reasonable scheduling and limiting the registration numbers. After 4 months of application, feedbacks were collected through questionnaire survey from both the teachers and residents. Clinical skills assessments were also taken to evaluate the teaching effect. Results: A total of 16 teachers and 8 residents participated in the supervised teaching clinic. The results of the questionnaire showed that 100% of the teachers and residents agreed with the teaching mode. The clinical skill assessment scores of the residents who participated in the teaching clinic were significantly higher than those of the control group (t=3.631, P<0.05). Conclusion: The application of supervised teaching clinic in standardized training of ophthalmology residents is feasible and can improve the clinical skills of the residents. 
论著

眼解剖整合课程在眼科住院医师规范化培训教学中的应用

The application of the integrated course on ocular anatomy in the standardized training teaching of ophthalmology residents

:483-490
 
目的:探索和评价“线上教学-理论小课-Wetlab实操”眼解剖整合课程在眼科住院医师培范化培训(住培)教学中的应用和效果。方法:纳入中山大学中山眼科中心2023年新入培的住培学员93名,在岗前培训时进行眼解剖整合课程教学。在课程前后分别进行测试,评价课程教学效果,并在课程结束后采用匿名线下测试考核和满意度问卷调查的形式对课程的满意度进行调查。结果:培训前(T1)和培训后(T2)总分中位数分别是60分和70分,T1最低分、25%、75%和最高分分别是10、40、62.5和90,T2最低分、25%、75%和最高分分别是30、60、80和100,T2得分显著高于T1得分,差异具有统计学意义(P<0.000 1);T1和T2的自信度平均值分别为26.53±5.08、31.83±4.02,差异有统计学意义(P<0.001)。学员普遍表示对整合课程满意。结论:学员们接受整合课程培训后,对眼解剖学知识的掌握程度有明显提高,对整合课程满意度高。眼解剖整合课程有效性显著,是具有推广意义的教学改革。
Objective: To explore and evaluate the application and effect of an integrated   ocular anatomy course comprising three main components: ‘online preview,’ ‘lecture,’ and ‘Wetlab dissection training’in the standardized training teaching of ophthalmology residents (hereinafter referred to as "resident training"). Methods: A total of 93 new resident trainees from Zhongshan Ophthalmic Center of Sun Yat-sen University in 2023 were included in the integrated course on ocular anatomy during pre-job training. Tests were carried out before and after the course to evaluate the teaching effect of the course, and questionnaires were issued after the course to investigate the satisfaction of the course. It adopts the form of anonymous offline test and satisfaction questionnaire. Results: The median total scores before (T1) and after (T2) training were 60 and 70, respectively; the lowest scores, 25%, 75% and highest scores of T1 were 10, 40, 62.5 and 90, respectively; the lowest scores, 25%, 75% and highest scores of T2 were 30, 60, 80 and 100, respectively, and the scores of T2 were significantly higher than those of T1. The difference was statistically significant (P<0.000 1). The mean confidence of T1 and T2 were 26.53±5.08 and 31.83±4.02, respectively, and the difference was statistically significant (P<0.001). Participants generally expressed satisfaction with the integrated programme. Conclusions: After receiving the training of the integrated course, the students' mastery of the knowledge of ocular anatomy has been significantly improved, and the satisfaction of the integrated course is high. The integrated course on ocular anatomy is effective, and it is a teaching reform with popularization significance.
论著

压核进钩劈核技术在白内障手术培训中的应用研究

A study of the press-and-chop technique in cataract surgery training

:340-347
 

目的:探讨压核进钩劈核技术在白内障超声乳化摘除手术培训中的应用效果。方法:采用回顾性研究。选取2019年1月—2023年12月在广东省中医院珠海医院眼科学习超声乳化白内障吸除术的30名学员为研究对象,所有对象培训周期均为3个月,分为乳化劈核教学组和压核进钩劈核教学组,统计学员第一次完成劈核前的猪眼手术量、第一次完成全部手术步骤前的猪眼手术量、一次性完整完成二分核的次数,培训结束时对学员进行猪眼手术操作考核并记录评分,采用问卷调查对两种教学方式进行评价。结果:压核进钩劈核教学组第一次完成劈核前的平均猪眼手术量为36.69(19,50)个,低于乳化劈核教学组的49.86(29,66)个(U=-3.08,P<0.05);压核进钩劈核教学组第一次完成全部手术步骤前的平均猪眼手术量为58.13(31,79)个,低于乳化劈核教学组73.14(50,90)个(U=-2.66,P<0.05);压核进钩劈核教学组一次性完整完成二分核的次数为14.75(9,22)次,高于乳化劈核教学组6.79(3,14)(U=4.02,P<0.05);压核进钩劈核教学组学员动物眼手术碎核步骤平均分为4.50(3,5),高于乳化劈核教学组的3.71(2,5)次(U=2.23,P<0.05);完整手术考核总分平均分为29.00(23,33)分,高于乳化劈核教学组的23.07(19,28)分(U=3.98,P<0.05)。培训结束时,压核进钩劈核教学组学员评价教学效果调查问卷总评分平均为18.31(15,20)分,高于乳化劈核教学组15.07(12,18)(U=3.69,P<0.05)。结论:核进钩劈核技术有助于学员更快地掌握碎核技术,缩短白内障超声乳化摘除手术的学习曲线,增强学习白内障手术的信心,提高超声乳化白内障吸除术的教学效果和满意度。

Objective:To investigate the effect of the press-and-chop technique in cataract phacoemulsification training. Methods:From January 2019 to December 2023, 30 trainees who studied cataract phacoemulsification surgery in the ophthalmology department of Guangdong Hospital of Traditional Chinese Medicine,Zhuhai were selected as the research subjects. The training period for all subjects was 3 months, and they were divided into two groups: phaco-chop teaching group and press-and-chop teaching group. The quantity of porcine eye surgeries performed by each trainee before completing the first nuclear chopping, the quantity of porcine eye surgeries performed before completing all surgical steps for the first time, and the number of times of complete nuclear chopping in one attempt were recorded. At the end of the training, the trainees were assessed on their ability to perform porcine eye surgeries and their scores were recorded. A questionnaire survey was conducted to valuate the two teaching methods. Results:The average number of porcine eye surgeries performed by the press-and-chop teaching group before completing the first nuclear chopping was 36.69 (19,50), which was lower than the phaco chop teaching group's 49.86 (29,66);The average number of porcine eye surgeries performed by the press-and-chop teaching group before before the first completion of all surgical steps was 58.13 (31, 79), which was lower than the phaco chop teaching group's 73.14 (50, 90).The average number of complete nuclear chopping in one attempt in the press-and-chop teaching group was 14.75 (9,22), which was higher than the phaco chop teaching group's 6.79 (3,14);The average score of the chopping step of porcine eye surgery for the press-and-chop teaching group was 4.50 (3,5), which was higher than the phaco chop teaching group's 3.71 (2,5);The average score for the press-and-chop teaching group of the complete surgery examination was 29.00 (23, 33), which was higher than the phaco chop teaching group's 23.07 (19, 28).At the end of the training, the average score of the survey questionnaire on the evaluation of teaching effectiveness by the press-and-chop teaching group was 18.31 (15, 20), which was higher than that of the phaco chop, which was 15.07 (12, 18). Conclusions:The press-and-chop technique helps trainees to master the chopping technique faster, shorten the learning curve of cataract phacoemulsification surgery, enhance confidence in learning cataract surgery, and improve the teaching effectiveness and satisfaction of cataract phacoemulsification surgery

综述

人文素养在眼科住院医师规范化培训中的重要性

Role of humanistic accomplishment in the standardized training of ophthalmology residents

:105-109
 
本文简要探讨了眼科青年医师在住院医师规范化培训过程中,应该重视人文素养的培养。眼科住院医师必须三基扎实,具备敏锐的临床科研嗅觉、优秀的现代医学人文素养。在科技高速发展与医疗环境日趋复杂的今天,培养具备精湛的专业技能与高尚的医学人文精神的眼科学领袖,对于眼科的发展显得尤为重要。
This article briefly discusses that in the process of standardized training of ophthalmology residents, the young physicians should focus on the training of humanistic accomplishment. Ophthalmology residents should master solid basic theory and skills, have keen sense of the clinical issue, and possess excellent modern medical humanities. Nowadays, it is particularly important to cultivate the ophthalmology leaders who hold superb professional skills and noble humanistic spirit because of the high-speed development of science and technology and the increasingly complex medical environment. 
论著

LRC 渐进协作教学体系在眼科培训中的设计与实践

Design and Implementation of the LRC Stepwise Collaborative Learning Model in Ophthalmology Training

:259-265
 
目的:以提升进行住院医师规范化培训(住培)的眼科医生临床诊疗思维能力为导向,建立LRC渐进协作教学体系(LRC Stepwise Collaborative Learning Model)。方法:2023年7月—2023年12月,以26名进行眼科住培的医生为试验组的研究对象,采用小讲课(Lecture)、教学查房(Rounds)及病例讨论(Case discussion)的LRC渐进协作教学体系,通过定量分析方法评估教学效果。结果:实施LRC渐进协作教学模式后,住培医生平均成绩由培训前的50.00 (40, 50)分提高至培训后的90.00 (80, 100)分,差异具有统计学意义(P<0.001)。问卷调查满分5分,小讲课、教学查房和病例讨论三种教学形式的满意度满分比例分别为92.3%(24/26),84.6%(22/26)、76.9%(20/26),三种教学形式的满意评分分别为5.00 (5.00, 5.00)、5.00 (5.00, 5.00)、5.00 (4.75, 5.00)分。结论:LRC渐进协作教学体系作为住培教学新体系,得到眼科住培医生的认可,促进临床诊疗思维的整体提升,有助于岗位胜任力的培养,为未来教学模式的设计与实施提供了重要参考。
Objective: To introduce the LRC Stepwise Collaborative Learning Model, a novel teaching approach designed to improve clinical thinking skills in ophthalmology training. Methods: From July 2023 to December 2024, 26 ophthalmology residents were included in the experimental group, underwent training using LRC Stepwise Collaborative Learning Model of Lectures, Rounds and Case Discussions. Their educational outcomes were quantitatively analyzed. Results: The LRC Stepwise Collaborative Learning Model improved average resident scores from pre-training [50(40, 50) points] to post-training [90(80,100) points], with a statistical significance (< 0.001). The questionnaire survey had a maximum score of 5 points, and the rates of full marks for the three teaching forms of lectures, rounds, and case discussions were 92.3% (24/26), 84.6% (22/26), and 76.9% (20/26), respectively. The satisfaction scores for the three teaching forms were 5.00 (5.00, 5.00), 5.00 (5.00, 5.00), and 5.00 (4.75, 5.00) points, respectively. Conclusions: The LRC Stepwise Collaborative Learning Model, as a new training system for residency education, has been recognized by ophthalmology residents. It facilitates the overall improvement of clinical thinking, contributes to competency development, and provides valuable insights for future teaching model designs.
论著

EYESi模拟器结合Wet-lab在白内障手术培训中的效果评价

Effect evaluation of EYESi simulator combined with Wet-lab in cataract surgery training

:736-745
 
目的:比较单一EYESi虚拟手术模拟器(Dry-lab)、Wet-lab以及两种方式联合教学在超声乳化白内障吸除显微手术培训中的效果及差异,以期探索更科学高效的教学方式。方法:选取中山大学中山眼科中心接受住院医师规范化培训的1年级住院医师18名,随机分为Dry-lab组、Wet-lab组和联合组,每组各6人,分别接受8次有效Dry-lab训练、8次Wet-lab训练、4次有效Dry-lab训练联合4次Wet-lab训练。培训前后问卷调查评估三种教学方式的模拟效果与学员满意度,并在猪眼模型上考核超声乳化白内障吸除手术的三个主要步骤,以评估学员的培训效果。结果:Dry-lab与Wet-lab训练均能有效帮助学员学习使用显微器械,操作手感较好。但在立体感(P=0.007)、与人眼操作相比近似度(P<0.001)以及对掌握技术的帮助度(P=0.003)上,Wet-lab优于Dry-lab训练;而在缩短培训用时(P<0.001)上,Dry-lab培训更具优势。联合培训模式培训效果优于单一Wet-lab训练(P=0.014)和模拟器培训(P=0.012),整体满意度高于Wet-lab训练(P=0.042)和Dry-lab培训(P=0.042)。结论:Dry-lab与Wet-lab训练在超声乳化白内障吸除显微手术培训中各有优势,而两者相结合的教学模式更为高效,培训效果更佳,整体满意度高。
Objective: To compare the effects and distinctions among three methods of phacoemulsification training: EYESi simulator (Dry-lab), Wet-lab, and a combined approach, in order to find out more scientific and efficient teaching method. Methods: 18 first-year residents undergoing residency training at Zhongshan Ophthalmic Center, Sun Yatsen University were randomly assigned to three groups: Dry-lab, Wet-lab, and Combined. Each group, consisting of 6 individuals, underwent a specific training regimen—8 sessions of effective simulator training for the Dry-lab group, 8 Wet-lab sessions for the Wet-lab group, and a combination of 4 effective simulator sessions with 4 Wet-lab sessions for the Combined group. The questionnaires were administered to assess simulation effects and student satisfaction before and after each training sessions. Additionally, the training effects were recorded in the three main steps of phacoemulsification cataract extraction surgery on a pig eye model. Results: Both the EYESi simulator and Wet-lab were proved to be effective in facilitating the learning of microscopic instrument use with commendable operating experience. However, Wet-lab is superior to the virtual simulator in terms of stereoscopic sensation (P=0.007), similarity to the human eye (P<0.001), and assistance in mastering techniques(P=0.003). Simulator training is found to be more advantageous in shortening the overall training time (P<0.001). The training effect of the joint training mode is better than that of single Wet-lab training (P=0.014) and simulator training (P=0.012), and the overall satisfaction is higher than that of Wet-lab training (P=0.042) and simulator training (P=0.042). Conclusion: The EYESi virtual surgery simulator and Wet-lab training have their advantages respectively in training for phacoemulsification cataract extraction microsurgery, and the combined teaching mode is more efficient, with better training effects and overall satisfaction.
其他期刊
  • 眼科学报

    主管:中华人民共和国教育部
    主办:中山大学
    承办:中山大学中山眼科中心
    主编:林浩添
    主管:中华人民共和国教育部
    主办:中山大学
    浏览
  • Eye Science

    主管:中华人民共和国教育部
    主办:中山大学
    承办:中山大学中山眼科中心
    主编:林浩添
    主管:中华人民共和国教育部
    主办:中山大学
    浏览